Tag Archives: fantasy

Sandry’s Book (Circle of Magic #1)

Title: Sandry’s Book

Author: Tamora Pierce

Series: Circle of Magic #1

Four children have come to Winding Circle temple from vastly different walks of life. A noble, a former Trader, a merchant’s child, and a thief, they have little in common except their inability to fit into traditional dormitories. But life in Discipline cottage unfolds unusual opportunities for Sandry, Tris, Daja, and Briar, who have magics that no one noticed . . .

This is a fun book. The beginning mixes up the timelines a bit, to show all four of the kids as they were when they started out, before Niko tracked them down, and how they got to Winding Circle. For some, like Sandry and Daja, it’s a tale of tragedy. For Briar and Tris, it’s more like hope.

The powers are also hinted at from the very beginning. Sandry can do magic with threads, string, weaving. Daja is drawn to metalwork. Tris is “haunted” by strange winds. And Briar is fascinated with green and growing things. But none of them consider this magic. I liked watching them connect with the adults who eventually become their mentors and friends, and gradually become friends with each other.

The big event at the end is interesting, too. The four of them need to work together, as might be expected, but the way they do so leaves a lot of ongoing consequences.

Overall this is a strong first book that introduces a lot of fun magical abilities. I rate this book Recommended.

AUDIOBOOK: The audio book version is excellent. It casts different people for the different characters, so the lines of dialogue are all distinctive.


The Book Eating Magician

Title: The Book Eating Magician

Author: Mekenlo / Translator: Rainbow Turtle

Status: 353 chapters (Ongoing)

Location: https://www.wuxiaworld.com/novel/the-book-eating-magician

Theodore Miller wants nothing more than to be a magician. And he’s brilliant at studying, insatiably curious to learn new things, and dedicated to his schooling. That still hasn’t stopped him from failing the last year of university multiple times due to insufficient power to complete the practical exams. About to set off on his last repetition, Theodore finds a mysterious book in the library—one that bonds itself to his hand and demands to be fed books, or it will eat him instead. But the books Gluttony eats also offer small bonuses to Theodore . . .

The translation quality is excellent. I found almost zero mistakes in hundreds of chapters, and the text flows very nicely. This is a very readable edition, and I hope that if it ever gets an official translation it will sound as good.

Yes, there are a lot of chapters. But this does not feel anything like that long. The chapters are relatively short, and perhaps due to the serial format, something is always happening. Whether it’s Theodore’s initial experiments with the grimoire Gluttony, his clever approach to enemies, or the times the story pulls back to spotlight someone else showing off awesome power, something is always happening.

Theodore is finally able to rise through ranks he never hoped to reach before, but some of his enemies are so ridiculous there’s no way he can overpower them. So most of his fights are more about being smart about how he’ll use the various tricks he has available. And even then, sometimes it’s just about hanging on long enough for someone else to rescue him.

Theodore’s actual magical power, and sensitivity to magic, are terrible. Gluttony can boost him, if he feeds it the right books, but he’s still terrible for a long time. The scene where someone tries to help boost his sensitivity is funny because no one can believe he’s reacting so badly—everyone assumed his base level was much higher. I also find it interesting that it’s his sensitivity, more than his power, that’s the real block. He could buy things to increase power, but that doesn’t do him any good if he can’t use the power well.

I also really like Theo’s attitude. Before Gluttony, he’s persistent in the face of insurmountable odds. He just picks himself up to try again every time he fails, doesn’t complain, and studies harder. After Gluttony, he’s aware he’s only succeeding due to a “cheat,” and remains humble. He’s certainly aware of his own capabilities, but he’s polite, respectful, and far more interested in learning something new than showing off. His encounter with a bitter master of summoning magic is a good example: the man dislikes Theo for being stronger, but Theo’s interest in his life’s work despite the poor results eventually thaws him, and together they manage to work the kind of spell the master spent his whole life wanting to see. Also amusing to me was one part where Theodore is tackling an 1800 page book and has stayed up far too late reading the first 1050 pages . . . and his reaction is, only 750 pages to go! Onward! Which as someone who frequently loses sleep due to reading amused me greatly.

The secondary characters are also fascinating. I love that Theodore decides to trust Vince, the one professor who supported him as a student, with the truth about why can can suddenly surpass his old limits. That changes their relationship, but Vince remains a staunch supporter in every way he can, and Theodore respects him. Other favorites include Randolph, a mercenary Theodore met who becomes a friend, and Orta, the assassin’s assassin, head of the White Tower.

I like how the story circles back to characters. Someone will get focus for a while, then fade into the background, then pop up again later with some changes according to how they’ve pursued their own paths in the meantime. This keeps things fairly focused even though a long story, as new characters come in slowly and develop over time.

I also find it amusing that even though Theo is technically gaining a string of girls who all like him, every time it’s about to get serious with one of them something happens. (My favorite is Gluttony interfering with a ‘Burning Carnal Desire’ curse and Theo reflexively attacking the cause.)

This is my first real experience with reading web novels, but it’s been so good I’m eager to look into more. The blend of action, adventure, and magic in this story is a whole lot of fun, and the chapters are so short it’s hard to stop. I rate this series Highly Recommended.


Talons of Power (Wings of Fire #9)

Title: Talons of Power

Author: Tui T. Sutherland

Series: Wings of Fire #9

Darkstalker has returned from his two-millennium sleep. Turtle is certain this is a disaster, but he’s having trouble convincing other dragons. Darkstalker can be charming, but more importantly, he’s an animus, mind-reader, and can see the future. Turtle tries to recruit allies of his own and gather proof that his suspicions are well-founded.

This is probably the weakest book of the series so far, because it’s entirely setup for the next one (and that ending looks really bad for certain dragons). Turtle’s struggle is with how useless he feels, and how much he wants to blend into the background. This is a combination of poor physical abilities, wanting to hide his magic, and a traumatic event when he was younger that resulted in the deaths of his unborn sisters. But as an animus, and someone who acted immediately to keep Darkstalker’s attention (and therefore magic) away from him, Turtle is the only one capable of doing anything against Darkstalker.

But the “doing something” mostly involves following Darkstalker at a distance and praying for someone else to step in and be the hero. Animus magic has always been unbalanced but it’s frustrating that Darkstalker is just so massively overpowered.

Overall this is a necessary next step for the story but it isn’t as engaging as the ones that came before. I rate this book Recommended.

Tempests and Slaughter (The Numair Chronicles #1)

Title: Tempests and Slaughter

Author: Tamora Pierce

Series: The Numair Chronicles #1

Arram Draper is the youngest student at the University of Carthak. Thanks to his powerful Gift and boundless curiosity, he’s learning more than he ever could have imagined. And he’s even found unlikely friendships with two other prodigies: Ozorne, who has connections to the Imperial family, and Varice, who wants to specialize in kitchen magics. But underneath everyday life at the university, sinister plots are brewing against the Imperial line.

This is the magical equivalent to the Alanna and Kel series. Arram’s magical curriculum actually has fairly little detail aside from the class names and broad generalities about what he studies. There isn’t much more here about how the Gift works or the techniques people use. What the story focuses on is more the school life, and the types of assignments Arram takes on, like learning healing firsthand at a plague center when disease strikes.

It helps to have read the Daine quartet beforehand but isn’t strictly necessary. Ozorne is a good friend to Arram, but he’s got some noticeable personality flaws that only worsen as the other heirs start dying off and pushing him closer to the throne. And his mother is crazy (possibly from grief, or possibly she’s just always been cracked), but she has enough power that no one can do anything about it.

I especially liked the mythological bits that sneak in, like Enzi, the male crocodile god. He’s probably helping Arram, in his own way, but he’s also a crocodile with a crocodile sense of humor. Preet, of course, is another highlight. I don’t wonder that she’s getting as educated as Arram in all the classes she attends with him.

I disliked the whole “let’s have a sex education talk” bit at the beginning. The book’s barely started, and pretty much the first thing that happens is Arram having erections and going through puberty. Given that the rest of the book is him so wrapped up in his studies he’s barely noticing girls, it’s especially out of place. I’m here to read an adventure, not a sex ed lecture.

Some of the cameos felt a little forced, too, although some of them were fun nods. I think the Coopers show up as the authors of three different books. Another character wasn’t obvious until his name gets revealed, and once that happens the story switches to using the more familiar name.

Overall this is another mostly solid chapter of backstory. There isn’t a whole lot done or resolved in this book, as it’s mostly Arram’s continuing education, but it’s setting up a number of things that will be more important down the road. I rate this book Recommended.

Have Sword, Will Travel

Title: Have Sword, Will Travel

Author: Garth Nix and Sean Williams

When Odo and Eleanor go fishing for eels in the drying up Silverrun river, they never expected to find a sword. Odo accidentally woke it up, which is how they discovered Biter was not just a sword, but an enchanted sword with very firm ideas about the knight who would wield him.

This was okay. Odo is the cautious and strong side of the partnership, whereas Eleanor is the quick and clever. Odo is also the one who doesn’t care about going on an adventure, which of course means he’s the one to end up with Biter. Between Biter and Eleanor, he doesn’t have a chance to say no.

I liked the unexpected way Eleanor’s jealousy played out. Both of them are hoping Biter can be convinced to take another master eventually, but then Eleanor tries to take matters into her own hands and ends up with a possible curse to figure out. And when they meet a female knight, both of them realize it’s not going to be as easy as letting someone else go after the dragon blocking the river.

Biter has as much personality as both kids. His insistence on doing things according to knightly rules can be amusing.

I do find myself rolling my eyes at the second confrontation with the knight. The kids have had mere days of training, and that while on the road. Sure, the enchanted weapon helps, but the victory is implied to be skill-based, not random luck. Perhaps I’m spoiled by my recent reading, which featured a much more in-depth depiction of the skills required to make a knight.

Overall this isn’t bad, but it didn’t really grab me either. I rate this book Recommended.


The Steel of Raithskar (The Gandalara Cycle #1)

Title: The Steel of Raithskar

Author: Randall Garrett and Vicki Ann Heydron

Series: The Gandalara Cycle #1

Ricardo is a university professor nearing the end of his life. A terminal diagnosis has led him to take a cruise around Europe, but his planned vacation ends with the fiery impact of a meteor. But he wakes up, on another world, in another body. Another life. A second chance. But living means taking on the identity of Markasset, the former owner of that body, and Markasset had problems of his own . . .

I read this once years ago and never got around to finishing the series, so I thought I’d give it another go.

The characters can be pretty thin. Illia, Markasset’s girlfriend, is probably the worst drawn of the main cast. She’s beautiful and interested in Markasset, and that is the extent of her characterization. Zaddorn, the police chief that Ricardo inadvertently crosses, is better but still fairly straightforward: he wants to recover the stolen jewel and thinks Markasset either did it or has answers about what happened. Thanasset, Markasset’s father, has the most depth. He recognizes immediately that his son is not the same, although he’s also remarkably quick to come to terms with his son’s death.

The plot is a bit better. Ricardo tries to analyze the new world in which he finds himself, piecing together what clues he notices to try to figure out who he is supposed to be, and later on, what happened to the jewel that was stolen. He can’t even say with any certainty that the body he wears now DIDN’T do it. And I liked that although Zaddorn is an antagonist, Ricardo has a great deal of sympathy for the man, as he’s only trying to do his job.

I also liked Keeshah, the gigantic cat that Markasset had bonded. In this dry, desert world, the cats are used as mounts by those who have bonded them (everyone else goes on foot). It’s a little strange to me that a meat-eater would be the largest creature in the desert, but I do like the relationship between him and Keeshah. The cat, of course, knows that Ricardo is not Markasset. But Keeshah’s trust opens a number of opportunities for Ricardo, not the least of which is the ability to get from place to place much faster than anyone else.

Overall I’m ambivalent on the series so far. I’m not particularly fond of any of the characters except Keeshah, but the plot was decent, and the book is short enough that it’s not a slog. I rate this book Neutral.


Summer’s Fall (Of Cats and Dragons #3)

Title: Summer’s Fall

Author: Carol E. Leever and Camilla Ochlan

Series: Of Cats and Dragons #3

Omen’s penchant for adventure has been tempered by Kyr. Taking care of his older-little brother is enough of a handful, even without two talking cats that cheerfully complicate life even more. But when Tormy is recruited to help solve a kidnapping, Omen ends up on another adventure, like it or not . . .

I received an advance copy and was asked to give an honest review. I bought the book anyway because I loved it.

These books just keep getting funnier. It’s hard to tell how much of the cats’ innocence is real and how much is an act. They certainly know how to cause trouble (as Dev notes, anyone with less connections and wealth than Omen’s family would probably go bankrupt trying to care for Tormy). The scene where Fog, another talking cat, comes to recruit Tormy for a “secret mission” was my favorite part, but pretty much everything they do is great fun.

I love Omen’s new awkwardness in trying to take care of Kyr. He wants so badly to give Kyr everything Kyr was missing, and has no idea how to deal with Kyr’s ramblings. As a reader, it’s fairly obvious that Kyr is seeing things on multiple levels at once, but Kyr can’t distinguish between what only he can see and what everyone can see.

Templar returns! I love how he and Omen play off each other. The new additions to the adventure are equally intriguing. Devastation Machelli looks to have a backstory just as interesting as Omen and Templar, for all that he’s not sharing much of it yet. Dev’s lackadaisical attitude and finely-tuned ability to annoy people made me laugh, especially because his target of choice is Avarice. I love the names in this family. Shalonie provides some much-needed level-headedness and the general smarts to balance out the boys.

And Devastation is just the best. He’s turned trolling into an art form.

“Surely you’ve already told my mother everything there is to say,” he groused. “You can’t possibly have anything more to tell her.”
Dev’s lips twitched upward as he continued to write. “You are correct,” he agreed mildly. “I don’t think she’ll ever use the term ‘excruciating detail’ around me again.”
Omen blinked at him in shock. “You’re purposely annoying my mother by writing nonsense to her?”
“Oh, we passed annoying days ago,” Dev replied.

The action scenes remain strong, too. A gigantic sea monster nicknamed the Widow Maker has shown up off the coast of Melia, and it has a particular interest in Kyr. But Omen and Kyr need to get past it somehow to complete their quest. This is a difficult fight since their opponent is monstrously big, out in the ocean, and attacks mentally as well as physically.

Overall, this is just the first part of the quest line, but it introduces several engaging new characters and sets up an epic adventure. You could technically start with this book but I would encourage you to read the first two books because they’re amazing and will help set the stage. I rate this book Highly Recommended.