Title: The Rising of the Shield Hero #10
Author: Aneko Yusagi
Format: Light Novel
The recovery of the Spirit Tortoise’s energy has given Naofumi a whole three and a half months to rest. And he’ll need it, as he, Raphtalia, and Filo are suffering the effects of his latest use of his Wrath shield. In the meantime, Naofumi turns his thoughts towards training an army to help him out, and he has just the place (and people) in mind.
This volume unfortunately slides back into a lot of the antics that I really hate. The whole scene with Keel felt unnecessary (and really, WHY did we have to go in this direction?). Instead of making Keel a girl and awkwardly making comments on sexual preferences to someone who is mentally still about 10 (and the incredibly stupid pronouncement forbidding relationships that follows), I would’ve preferred some actual character development and not a rehash of the same kind of shticks that show up in countless anime/manga/light novels.
Besides, the cast is desperately in need of males who aren’t stupid. Right now only the weapon shop owner qualifies (I’d give L’Arc more credit if he was a local, but we’re not likely to see him again for a while). I had been hoping Keel could grow up to be the male equivalent of Raphtalia, someone Naofumi can speak frankly with as more of a peer, without the romantic angle. Instead we get Keel as a girl, and the end of the book has yet another girl joining the party (and one who’s not at all shy about making her intentions known).
I did like that the immediate focus is more on rebuilding. The Coliseum ensures there will still be interesting fights even as the quieter work of setting up a new home begins. Naofumi hasn’t really had any place in this world to call home before now. Even now he’s more considering this territory a place to raise an army than a place to live, but I suspect once he has a home the way Kizuna did his attitude will start to change. The little touches of longing visible when he considered her home imply he really wants that kind of a place for himself.
The whole slavery angle is also a mixed bag. Naofumi is doing good things in questionable ways, which is kind of how he’s operated all along. Even though he’s correct that his bonuses will help everyone level better as slaves, he’s never been willing to consider releasing Raphtalia or Filo from the spells that he could use to control them. He’s likely to make excuses about releasing the others too, even though they aren’t as close. And Naofumi’s actions prop up the slave market, making him responsible for the kind of demand that caused Raphtalia to get kidnapped into slavery in the first place.
It was funny what Naofumi considers an appropriate punishment for the people who caused so much trouble to Raphtalia and her village in the first place. It is entirely fitting—those who were only concerned about the money ran into someone using their own values against them.
I also liked the small twists on the whole Coliseum trope—Naofumi’s just in this to get rich quick. Betting on his own party and then sweeping a tournament seems like the best way to get a massive return on his investment. His interactions with Nadia help expose that this isn’t going to be quite as simple as he was expecting, but it’s too late to back out.
Overall this is a quieter book, but the main reason I feel it’s a step back from the stronger arc recently is the focus on really stereotypical harem antics. If you’ve followed the series up until this point, the last book wouldn’t be a bad place to stop, at least until the current arc can prove if it’s going to get back on track. I rate this book Neutral.